Prologue Era:
2003:
- Luke Osmon, Alexander Mckaven, and Lily Rose arrive to Earth.
Beginning Era:
2012:
- Luke Osmon separates his good and evil halves, and it forms Defeated Cat and Black Cat, respectively.
- Defeated Cat meets William Johnson.
- Defeated Cat meets Oliver Macdonald.
- Defeated Cat figures out how to share magic with his teammates and gives Oliver Macdonald a lot more than he gives to William Johnson.
- Defeated Cat forms an alliance, known as Team Bright Side.
- Black Cat meets Lawrence Forrest and they form an alliance, known as Team Dark Side.
2013:
- Defeated Cat meets Jason Patterson.
- Defeated Cat shares magic with Jason Patterson, officially recruiting him.
- Defeated Cat forms the Power of Three (1st Generation), alongside Oliver Macdonald and Jason Patterson.
2014:
- Defeated Cat meets Zachary Wass, and recruits him.
- Zachary Wass is transformed into White Cat, and gains magic from Defeated Cat.
- Oliver Paver has a lava accident, turning him into a lava monster and creeper hybrid.
2015:
- Defeated Cat meets Kyra Jeffery.
- Alexander Mckaven is recruited by Defeated Cat and joins Team Bright Side.
- Defeated Cat meets Camille Pfister.
2016:
- Defeated Cat meets Mary Tan, briefly acquainting with her sister, Kimberly Boo-Tan.
- Black Cat meets Celeste Michaels, and officially recruits her.
- William Johnson goes missing.
- Defeated Cat meets Christopher Torelli.
- Lily Rose is recruited by Defeated Cat and joins Team Bright Side.
- Black Cat meets and recruits Oliver Paver.
- Defeated Cat meets Oliver Paver.
Middle Era:
2017:
- Oliver Macdonald goes missing.
- Jason Patterson goes missing.
- Defeated Cat meets Lucas Cuellar.
- Defeated Cat forms the new Power of Three (2nd Generation) with Zachary Wass and Kyra Jeffery.
2018:
- Defeated Cat confirms that his friends William Johnson, Oliver Macdonald and Jason Patterson, are indeed dead and frozen to stone by Black Cat.
- Oliver Paver betrays Team Dark Side and joins Team Bright Side.
- Black Cat murders Christopher Torelli as revenge for Oliver Paver's betrayal.
- Black Cat murders Oliver Paver.
- Kyra Jeffery disappears.
2019:
- Delaney Forrest murders Celeste Michaels to get revenge on Team Dark Side for "corrupting" her husband, Lawrence Forrest.
- Clarence Forrest confronts his mom (Delaney Forrest), about her cheating on his dad (Lawrence Forrest), and ends up killing her in pure rage.
- Delaney Forrest exposes the truth to Clarence Forrest about his father, Lawrence Forrest's affiliation with Team Dark Side before she passes away.
- Black Cat and Lawrence Forrest clean up after Delaney Forrest's murder, and use it to peer pressure Clarence Forrest to join Team Dark Side, and in turn conceal the truth of what he did.
2020:
- Defeated Cat and Black Cat begin to burn out and run out of hate for each other, as well as the energy to try and keep ruining the other.
Finale Era:
2021:
- Defeated Cat and Black Cat agree that they have grown and changed over the years, and don't add up to what they were originally made for, coming to terms with the fact that they will be best as one being instead of two. Their merge forms the new Rylie Osmon.
- Rylie Osmon dissolves Team Bright Side and Team Dark Side, and forms a new alliance known as Team Both Sides.
2022:
- Kyra Jeffery reappears for the first time since 2018, proving she is still alive.
2023:
- Camille Pfister talks to a frustrated and confused Rylie Osmon about their feelings, and helps them to realize they need a break.
- Rylie Osmon changes their uniform that they've had the past two years to symbolize a focus on the "bright side", once again.
- Alexander Mckaven gives up on trying to be close to his siblings with Rylie Osmon leaving.
- Lily Rose goes off to find herself with the express condition that if she is ever needed, she will come back and help, unlike Alexander Mckaven.
- Kyra Jeffery in a PTSD response runs away again, but secretly stays close, keeping an eye on things.
- Rylie Osmon steps down from Team Both Sides and promotes Lucas Cuellar in their place, instead of letting Zachary Wass fill the role immediately.
- Rylie Osmon sells their house and their things, then leaves Earth.
- Every1-2gether, LLC's first board meeting without Rylie Osmon as the chairman.
- Zachary Wass heavily spirals about being blocked from getting the Primary Co-Leader position for Team Both Sides by Rylie Osmon, and having Lucas Cuellar steal his job.
- Zachary Wass and Lucas Cuellar bond over Rylie Osmon's departure, and Lucas Cuellar gives Zachary Wass Primary Co-Leader, finally, and steps down to Secondary Co-Leader.
- Clarence Forrest is promoted within Team Both Sides, and gets on the board of directors for Every1-2gether, LLC, in turn.
- Every1-2gether, LLC's first board meeting without Lucas Cuellar as the chairman, replaced by Zachary Wass, instead.
2024:
- Kyra Jeffery is found by Lucas Cuellar and Zachary Wass nearby, coming back with them to help.
- Clarence Forrest resigns and runs away, afraid of being replaced by Kyra Jeffery. Though, his disappearance forces this to happen, anyways.
- Kyra Jeffery is promoted to Clarence Forrest's old position on the board for Every1-2gether, LLC.
- Rylie Osmon, looking different from before, returns to Earth for a visit with their friends Zachary Wass, Lucas Cuellar, and Kyra Jeffery.
- Rylie Osmon leaves Earth once again, only to feel a darkness as they depart, being wary of it.
- Kyra Jeffery receives a message in her head from Rylie Osmon, using telepathy, warning her of the darkness. She then warns Zachary Wass and Lucas Cuellar.
2025:
- Rylie Osmon dies in attempt to destroy the magic that fails, but mostly succeeds.